Skip to main content

Does Facebook’s Civil Rights Audit Target Free Speech?

Share This article

Watch CBN News Reporter Charlene Aaron's story above.

Dan Gainor, vice president of business and culture for the Media Research Center, appeared on Tuesday's CBN Newswatch program to discuss how he believes Facebook's policies are targeting conservatives free speech. 

Facebook recently released the results of its civil rights audit in an effort to fight hate speech on its platform.

The company said it is rolling out the updated guidelines to prevent harmful content, fight discrimination in Facebook Ads, and protect the 2020 Census and Elections from intimidation.

The audit, headed by former ACLU director Laura Murphy, includes the demands of 90 liberal organizations.

Many say the new policies take direct aim at conservative speech on Facebook.

"Sheryl Sandberg just announced that she is allowing the ACLU and 90 left-wing organizations to dictate nearly every aspect of Facebook's policies, Media Research Center President (MRC) Brent Bozell said in a statement.  "This will let the left dominate the most powerful social media platform on the face of the earth. That raises significant legal and statutory issues that should worry both left and right."

Bozell continued, "Facebook hasn't released the names of these groups, but the crux of their plans is clear – the influence of everything Facebook does from hiring more liberals to control of all content. That goes so far as to include advertising, partnerships and control of the product itself. Now these left-wing groups have the power over every post a conservative makes. Facebook can't be a free marketplace of ideas with the left controlling everything and the firm's No. 2 overseeing and embracing all they are doing."

Facebook COO Sheryl Sandberg shared about the changes on her Facebook page.

"We're making changes in four main areas – we're strengthening our policies and enforcement against hate and other harmful content; fighting discrimination in all ads on Facebook with special efforts in housing, employment and credit ads; protecting against misinformation in the 2020 Census and upcoming elections; and formalizing our civil rights task force," said Sandberg. 

Many conservatives already feel like second class citizens on social media. They say Facebook's policy changes ignore their concerns and only goes after the issues that liberals care about while downplaying freedom of speech.

MRC's Dan Gainor told CBN News he is not surprised by the tech giant's latest move.

"Surprised? No," said Gainor.  "Disappointed?  Yes."  

He said, "Here we are, it's been more than a year that Sen. John Kyle was doing supposedly a similar audit of conservatives. We've heard no hide nor hair of that. But this is the second time we've seen Facebook wrap its arms around the product of the former head of the ACLU and ninety liberal groups all basically getting control of the most powerful social media company in the history of mankind."       

CBN News recently reported on the story about Blaze TV host Graham Allen who was banned from Facebook after issuing a call to pray for President Trump.

"I made a video and I basically captioned it saying real Christians pray for everyone," Allen told CBN News.  "And a couple days later I got a notification from Facebook that I had violated their community standards for hate speech. So, they took the video down. They removed it.  I got no appeal process. No anything. And I just found it incredibly , incredibly sad that calling for prayer for the president of the United States was considered hate speech."

Evangelist Franklin Graham has also been suspended from Facebook in the past for taking a stand for his biblical beliefs.

The temporary ban lasted 24 hours, and while the censorship itself is shocking enough, it was also surprising that the ban was retroactive, resulting from a comment he made years prior.

President Trump recently accused Twitter of bias and censorship of conservative content.

In an interview with Fox Business, he said, "What they did to me on twitter is incredible.  I have millions of followers, but I will tell you, they make it very hard for people to join me in twitter and they make it very much harder for me to get out the message."

Gainor suggested what Facebook can do to ensure positive changes for both conservatives and liberals.

"If they were to embrace the ideal of the first amendment, then free speech becomes more important to them than safety," he said.  "And so, we can all be offended but we can all actually have our free speech online, and freedom of religion, and freedom of press, all the things that are in the first amendment."

Meanwhile, Bozell went on to say, "The company getting in bed with these liberal organizations – especially in its efforts to prepare for the 2020 elections – should be deeply alarming to the conservative movement, Congress, potentially the FEC, and indeed all Americans."

"This was a big mistake on Facebook's part. We hope they will rethink the decisions they have made."

Share This article

About The Author

Charlene Aaron

Charlene Aaron serves as a general assignment reporter, news anchor, co-host of The 700 Club, co-host of 700 Club Interactive, and co-host of The Prayerlink on the CBN News Channel. She covers various social issues, such as abortion, gender identity, race relations, and more. Before joining CBN News in 2003, she was a personal letter writer for Dr. Pat Robertson. Charlene attended Old Dominion University and Elizabeth City State University. She is an ordained minister and pastor’s wife. She lives in Smithfield, VA, with her husband.